The Real Cost of College: FAFSA, CSS Profile, and the Questions Every Family Should Be Asking

College costs feel overwhelming right now—and families are asking smarter, more nuanced questions than ever before. In this episode of Ol’ College Try, hosts Matt Carpenter and Peg Keough opened up the grab bag to tackle some of the most common (and most stressful) questions parents are facing as they navigate the college planning process.

From understanding the difference between FAFSA and the CSS Profile, to how rental properties, trusts, inheritances, and child support affect financial aid, to the growing anxiety around AI and the future of careers, this episode goes beyond the basics and digs into what really matters.

Below is a breakdown of the key insights every family should understand.

Federal Methodology vs. Institutional Methodology: Why This Difference Matters

One of the most important—and most misunderstood—topics in college financial aid is the difference between federal methodology (FM) and institutional methodology (IM).

Federal Methodology (FAFSA Schools)

Most colleges in the U.S. use the federal methodology, which is calculated through the FAFSA (Free Application for Federal Student Aid).

Key characteristics:

  • Transparent and relatively straightforward

  • Primarily looks at income and non-retirement assets

  • Does not consider home equity

  • Does not count small family-owned businesses (fewer than 100 employees)

  • For divorced or separated families, only the custodial parent’s finances are considered

Because of its simplicity, families can usually see exactly how their numbers affect their Student Aid Index (SAI).

Institutional Methodology (CSS Profile Schools)

Roughly 250 colleges—mostly private and highly selective—use the institutional methodology, calculated through the CSS Profile.

Key differences:

  • Much less transparent

  • Home equity is often included

  • Businesses are always included, regardless of size

  • Both parents’ finances are considered, even if divorced or separated

  • Colleges have more discretion in how they interpret financial information

This is why understanding a college’s “business model” is critical. Two schools with the same sticker price can be wildly different in how affordable they are for your family.

Why Sticker Price Is Misleading (and Often Meaningless)

Sticker prices today can exceed $90,000–$100,000 per year—and that understandably causes panic. But Matt and Peggy emphasized an important truth:

Very few families should be paying full price.

The problem isn’t that college costs are high (though they are). The real issue is families trying to plan without understanding:

  • How each college calculates financial need

  • What assets are actually counted

  • Where appeals and negotiations are possible

When families understand the rules of the game, they often discover that schools they assumed were “too expensive” can actually be affordable—and schools they assumed were affordable may not be.

AI, Majors, and the Big Question: Is College Still Worth It?

Another major theme of this episode was anxiety about AI and the future of work.

With technology evolving faster than ever, parents are understandably asking:

  • Will AI eliminate entire careers?

  • Is college still a good investment?

  • How do we help kids choose majors in an unpredictable future?

The Big Picture

No one has a crystal ball—but history gives us clues. Just as the internet disrupted industries while creating entirely new ones, AI is likely to do the same.

Matt emphasized that college still provides:

  • Adaptability and critical thinking skills

  • Exposure to emerging ideas and industries

  • A foundation for navigating change

Peg added an important caveat:

College is still worth it—but not at any price.

Paying full sticker price for a degree with unclear ROI can be risky. But attending college at the right price keeps the investment reasonable—even in a rapidly changing world.

Relationships Still Matter

One thing AI can’t replace? Human relationships.

College remains one of the most powerful environments for:

  • Building lifelong friendships

  • Creating professional networks

  • Learning how to collaborate and communicate

In a future where resumes may be scanned by algorithms, personal recommendations and real relationships may matter more than ever.

Rental Properties and LLCs: How They Affect Financial Aid

Families who own rental properties often worry about how those assets will be treated.

If the Property Is in an LLC:

  • FAFSA:

    • Small family-owned businesses are excluded

    • The value of the property is not counted

    • The income still appears on tax returns and is considered

  • CSS Profile:

    • Businesses are fully disclosed

    • Colleges examine tax returns closely

    • Depreciation and expenses may be adjusted by the school

This is a major difference between FM and IM schools—and often triggers the need for a financial aid appeal.

Inheritances and Trusts: Can They Be “Sheltered”?

A sensitive but common question:

If I’m expecting an inheritance and plan to use it for retirement, does putting it in a trust protect it from financial aid calculations?

Short answer: No.

Both FAFSA and CSS Profile ask directly about trusts. Unless the trust is completely separate and non-reportable (which is rare and complex), it must be disclosed.

There are financial tools that can shelter assets from aid calculations, but:

  • They are not one-size-fits-all

  • They often involve insurance or legal structures

  • They should never be done solely for financial aid reasons

As Peggy emphasized, financial aid decisions should never be made in a silo—tax, legal, and long-term planning consequences all matter.

Do You Have to Reapply for Financial Aid Every Year?

Yes—at least with FAFSA.

  • FAFSA: Required every year

  • CSS Profile: Depends on the school (many require it annually)

Even if a school doesn’t require the CSS Profile after freshman year, families should still proactively communicate changes in their financial situation.

And one key strategy remains consistent:

Appeal your financial aid every year.

Your best leverage is typically freshman year—but ongoing appeals can still uncover additional aid, especially if circumstances change.

Child Support and the Student Aid Index (SAI)

Recent changes have significantly improved how child support is treated.

  • Child support is no longer counted as income

  • It is now treated as an asset

  • This typically results in a much smaller impact on financial aid eligibility

For many families, the effect is now negligible—and in cases where child support is ending when college begins, appeals can be especially effective.

Final Takeaway: Knowledge Is Leverage

This episode made one thing clear: families who understand how the system works are far better positioned to avoid unnecessary costs.

College planning today isn’t just about filling out forms—it’s about:

The more informed you are, the less intimidating—and expensive—the process becomes.

cost of college

Click Here to Subscribe & Listen the Full Episode!