When it comes to choosing a college, parents want to get everything right. From finding the best academic programs to securing scholarships and making sure their child will be happy, there are countless decisions to make along the way.

But what happens when you’re a college financial planning expert going through the process with your own child?

As it turns out, even the experts discover a few surprises.

college planning isn’t just about getting accepted into a prestigious university or receiving the largest scholarship. It’s about finding a school where your student can thrive academically, socially, and financially.

And sometimes, the best college decision isn’t the one parents originally imagined.

In This Episode of Ol’ College Try

In this episode of Ol’ College Try, College Aid Pro’s Peg Keough welcomes Chuck Bates, a financial advisor and College Aid Pro expert with nearly 15 years of experience helping families navigate the college admissions and financial aid process.

But this time, Chuck isn’t sharing advice from his professional experience alone.

He’s sharing his personal journey as a dad.

Chuck’s daughter, Kenzie, recently started her freshman year at Mississippi State University. Throughout the episode, Chuck reflects on how his family approached college visits, changing majors, scholarship opportunities, and ultimately choosing the right school.

Together, Peg and Chuck discuss the lessons they learned and offer practical college planning advice for parents who are preparing to navigate the process with their own students.

Their biggest takeaway? Trust your student, establish a realistic budget, and focus on finding a college where your child can genuinely thrive.

Why College Fit Matters More Than Rankings

It’s easy to get caught up in college rankings, acceptance rates, and prestigious university names.

But Peg emphasizes that these numbers don’t necessarily tell you whether a college will be a good fit for your child.

During the episode, she discusses how some universities have simplified their application requirements, making it easier for students to apply.

For example, Tulane University eliminated supplemental essays, and Peg references a significant increase in early action applications.

When more students apply but the number of available seats stays relatively consistent, a college’s acceptance rate can decrease.

That makes the school appear more selective.

But does it suddenly mean the college provides a better education or experience?

Not necessarily.

Peg encourages parents to focus on what she calls the “thrive factor.”

Will your student be happy, supported, challenged, and successful at this school?

Chuck agrees, explaining that seeing his daughter thriving during her freshman year has been one of the most rewarding parts of the entire experience.

Ultimately, a college’s reputation matters far less than whether it’s the right environment for your student.

Start Exploring Colleges Earlier Than You Think

One of the most interesting parts of Chuck’s story is how early his daughter began experiencing college campuses.

Kenzie was a varsity golfer in high school, which gave her opportunities to attend golf camps at different universities.

These experiences allowed her to stay in dormitories, meet college students, and get a feel for campus life.

But Chuck’s family also took a much simpler approach.

Whenever they traveled, they would occasionally stop at a nearby college campus, walk around, and grab lunch.

There wasn’t always a scheduled tour or formal admissions presentation.

Sometimes they were simply exploring.

Why Informal College Visits Matter

These casual visits helped Kenzie discover what she liked and disliked about different campuses.

Some schools immediately appealed to her.

Others didn’t feel right.

And that’s valuable information.

Parents don’t necessarily need to schedule elaborate college tours during freshman or sophomore year.

Simply exposing students to different campus environments can help them begin identifying their preferences.

Do they like large universities or smaller campuses?

Do they prefer urban environments or traditional college towns?

Would they rather attend school close to home or experience a completely different part of the country?

Early exploration can make college planning feel less overwhelming when junior and senior year arrive.

It’s Okay If Your Student Changes Their Mind About Their Major

Kenzie initially thought she wanted to study marine biology.

She loved warm weather, spending time outdoors, and being near the ocean.

Her family even began exploring colleges with strong marine biology programs.

But then something changed.

During high school, Kenzie became involved in FFA, an organization focused on agricultural education and leadership.

She raised a pig named Wilbur during her junior year and a steer named Benny during her senior year.

These experiences introduced her to a completely different set of interests.

Eventually, she decided she wanted to pursue agricultural business.

How Changing Majors Can Change Your College List

Once Kenzie’s academic interests shifted, her family needed to reconsider which colleges made sense.

Instead of focusing primarily on marine biology programs, they began researching universities with strong agriculture programs.

That opened the door to schools such as:

  • Mississippi State University
  • Kansas State University
  • Oklahoma State University
  • University of Arkansas
  • North Carolina State University
  • University of Florida

Chuck explains that he wasn’t particularly concerned about the change.

His priority was finding a school where Kenzie would be happy, work hard, and have a realistic path toward graduating in four years.

For parents, this is an important reminder.

Your student doesn’t need to have their entire future figured out at 16 or 17.

Interests change, and sometimes extracurricular activities reveal career paths students never previously considered.

The goal is to remain flexible enough to adjust the college search as your student’s interests develop.

How to Build a College List That Balances Fit and Affordability

One of the biggest college planning mistakes families can make is focusing exclusively on a school’s published cost of attendance.

Chuck’s experience demonstrates why looking at net price is so important.

Kenzie applied to approximately 13 colleges, many of them public universities outside her home state of Texas.

While out-of-state public colleges are often assumed to be expensive, several institutions offered her significant scholarships.

Chuck explains that nearly every school that accepted Kenzie, with a few exceptions, offered enough financial assistance to bring the cost close to what his family would have paid at an in-state Texas university.

In fact, Mississippi State ended up being less expensive than some of their in-state options.

Sticker Price vs. Net Price

A college’s sticker price is its published cost before financial assistance.

Net price is the amount a family expects to pay after applicable grants and scholarships are deducted.

For example:

  • College A has a published annual cost of $55,000 and offers $25,000 in scholarships.
  • College B has a published annual cost of $35,000 and offers $5,000 in scholarships.

Both colleges would have an estimated net price of $30,000.

This is why families shouldn’t automatically eliminate colleges based on their advertised tuition.

Some universities, including certain out-of-state public institutions, offer substantial merit scholarships to attract strong applicants.

The key is identifying schools where your student’s academic profile and accomplishments make them competitive for institutional aid.

Why Setting a College Budget Early Is So Important

One of the smartest decisions Chuck and his wife made was establishing a maximum college budget before their daughter made her final decision.

Their family’s limit was $60,000 per year.

That doesn’t mean every family needs to spend that much.

For some families, the budget might be $15,000, $25,000, or $40,000 annually.

The important thing is determining what your family can realistically afford.

How Chuck’s Family Handled the Budget Conversation

When Kenzie expressed interest in a school that exceeded their budget, Chuck explained that she would need to cover the difference.

He also helped her understand the long-term financial consequences of spending more than the family could afford.

He joked that if he overspent on college, he might end up living in her basement because he hadn’t saved enough for retirement.

Kenzie understood the point.

And suddenly, the schools within their established budget looked much more appealing.

What Parents Can Learn

Peg encourages parents to discuss their financial boundaries before involving their children.

You don’t need to share every detail of your income, retirement accounts, or household finances.

But students should understand the amount their family can reasonably contribute.

This creates realistic expectations and prevents the disappointment of falling in love with a college that’s financially out of reach.

It also teaches students an important life lesson.

Financial decisions should be based on what you can afford, not simply what you want.

What Is Rolling Admission, and Why Can It Make Senior Year Easier?

Another important part of Kenzie’s experience involved rolling admissions.

Unlike colleges that release admission decisions on a specific date, schools with rolling admissions generally review applications as they arrive and issue decisions throughout the application cycle.

Kenzie completed her Common Application early and submitted applications to approximately 13 schools.

Because several universities used rolling admissions, she began receiving acceptance letters relatively quickly.

Within a couple of weeks, she had already received multiple offers.

Why Early Acceptances Can Reduce Stress

By October, Kenzie had several college options and was already leaning toward Mississippi State.

She had visited the campus twice and felt confident that it was the right place for her.

Rather than waiting for every remaining admission decision, she was ready to move forward.

For Chuck, this was surprising.

As a financial advisor who had helped hundreds of families, he expected his daughter to compare every possible offer before deciding.

But Kenzie was comfortable with her choice.

And ultimately, that confidence helped make the process less stressful.

Not every college offers rolling admissions, and application timelines vary.

However, researching admission policies and submitting applications early can help families understand their options sooner.

The Most Important College Planning Advice: Trust Your Student

One of Chuck’s biggest lessons from the experience was learning when to step back.

He admits that he occasionally struggled with wanting his daughter to explore opportunities that he believed could benefit her.

For example, Kenzie received an offer to join the University of Florida’s Innovation Academy.

Chuck thought the program sounded exciting and encouraged her to visit the campus.

But by that point, Kenzie had already decided she wanted to attend Mississippi State.

She wasn’t interested in reconsidering.

When Parents Need to Let Go

Chuck initially wondered whether she was overlooking a valuable opportunity.

But he eventually recognized something more important.

She was happy with her decision.

And she was confident in it.

His advice to parents comes down to two simple ideas:

Be patient.

Trust your student, not your own ego.

Peg agrees, explaining that parents can unintentionally influence their children by expressing strong preferences during campus visits.

Even when parents mean well, students may feel pressured to choose the college their family prefers.

Instead, parents should give students room to form their own opinions.

Of course, financial boundaries still matter.

But within those boundaries, the student should have a meaningful voice in deciding where they’ll spend the next four years.

One Simple Step That Could Improve Your Student’s Application

One of the most practical tips Chuck shares involves contacting admissions counselors after submitting applications.

Once Kenzie submitted her applications, she sent a short email to the admissions representative at each university.

She introduced herself, explained that she had applied, and expressed her excitement about the school.

Then she asked two questions:

  1. Is my application complete?
  2. Is there anything else I could do to strengthen my application?

Why Reaching Out Can Help

The responses varied.

Some admissions counselors simply confirmed that her application would be reviewed.

Others provided more specific guidance.

For example, a few suggested that improving her SAT or ACT scores could make her a stronger candidate.

Kenzie ultimately retook certain tests and submitted updated scores to schools where doing so might help.

This simple step gave her additional information that she might not have received otherwise.

It also demonstrated initiative.

While contacting an admissions counselor won’t guarantee admission or additional scholarships, it can help students confirm requirements and identify opportunities to improve their applications.

And it doesn’t require a complicated strategy.

Sometimes, asking a thoughtful question is enough.

Don’t Forget About Scholarships After Freshman Year

Many families assume that the scholarships a student receives when entering college will remain their only institutional awards.

But Chuck and Peg explain that additional opportunities may become available after freshman year.

During a visit to the University of Tennessee, Chuck’s family met with someone from the agriculture department.

They learned that while the department offered relatively limited scholarship funding for incoming freshmen, additional opportunities were available for sophomores and upperclassmen.

This was valuable information because it could potentially change the family’s long-term cost calculations.

Ask Academic Departments About Scholarships

Peg shares similar experiences involving students who received additional scholarships after enrolling.

Her son, for example, received departmental scholarships while attending Indiana University.

These opportunities aren’t always automatically awarded.

Students may need to research them, meet eligibility requirements, and submit applications.

Families should ask:

  • Does the academic department offer scholarships for current students?
  • Are awards available beginning sophomore year?
  • Are scholarships based on GPA, academic performance, or major?
  • Do students need to apply separately?
  • Can departmental scholarships be combined with existing financial aid?

One important consideration: never assume future scholarships are guaranteed when deciding whether a college is affordable.

Instead, treat them as potential opportunities that could reduce costs later.

How Much Should Parents Save for College?

Chuck also shares a simple way to think about college savings.

There are 216 months between a child’s birth and their 18th birthday.

That might sound like a long time, but those months can pass quickly.

Using an illustrative annual college cost of approximately $30,000 to $35,000, Chuck explains that saving around $150 per month over 216 months could accumulate enough contributions to cover roughly one year of college.

Saving approximately $600 per month over the same period could accumulate enough contributions to cover roughly four years at that illustrative cost.

These are simplified examples that don’t account for investment growth, inflation, taxes, or changes in college prices.

But they demonstrate an important principle.

Start Saving, Even If You Feel Behind

Chuck says he sometimes encounters families who avoid saving because they’re worried that having money in savings will reduce their financial aid eligibility.

But he encourages parents to think about the bigger picture.

If you don’t save anything, how will you pay for college?

Peg adds that even if your child is already in high school, it’s not too late to begin setting money aside.

You might not be able to cover the entire cost of college through savings alone.

But every dollar you save could reduce the amount your family eventually needs to borrow.

Effective college planning means preparing financially while also researching scholarships, grants, and affordable college options.

Why You Shouldn’t Rely on Other Parents’ Financial Aid Experiences

One of Peg’s final pieces of advice is to be careful about relying too heavily on friends, neighbors, or social media groups for college financial aid guidance.

It’s natural to ask other parents about their experiences.

But every family’s financial situation is different.

Two students with similar grades may receive completely different financial aid offers.

Even siblings attending the same college several years apart may receive different packages.

Why?

Because financial aid eligibility can depend on factors such as:

  • Family income and assets
  • Household circumstances
  • Student academic qualifications
  • Institutional scholarship policies
  • Changes in college costs and financial aid rules
  • The year a student applies

Colleges also change their admission and scholarship strategies over time.

A school that offered generous merit scholarships four years ago may approach awards differently today.

Peg encourages families to use reliable resources and evaluate their own circumstances rather than assuming someone else’s experience will apply to them.

Use Tools to Estimate Your Actual College Costs

Chuck recommends that families begin exploring college costs early using MyCAP.

The platform allows families to estimate financial aid eligibility and compare potential college costs based on their financial circumstances.

Instead of waiting until senior year to discover that a favorite college may be unaffordable, families can begin researching realistic options much earlier.

You can create a free MyCAP account to start exploring schools and estimating costs.

The Bottom Line

The college admissions process can feel overwhelming, even for families who understand financial aid and college costs.

But Chuck’s experience with his daughter is a reminder that successful college planning isn’t about controlling every decision or finding the most prestigious university.

It’s about preparing early, staying flexible, setting realistic financial boundaries, and trusting your student to help determine where they’ll thrive.

Start exploring campuses before senior year. Encourage your student to discover their interests. Compare colleges based on net price rather than sticker price. Ask admissions counselors questions, research scholarship opportunities, and establish a budget your family can afford.

And most importantly, remember that your student’s college experience belongs to them.

As Chuck discovered, one of the most rewarding parts of the journey isn’t receiving an acceptance letter.

It’s watching your child find a place where they’re happy, independent, and excited about their future.

The best college isn’t necessarily the most selective or expensive. It’s the one where your student can thrive without putting your family’s financial future at risk.